Resurrection TV Review – ABC Looks To Reclaim LOST Viewers

ABC has been trying to hit on a lot of fronts lately, but nothing has been a more clear shot at fans of LOST than the upcoming Resurrection. The trailers don’t exactly give you that impression (see sizzle reel below), but they hint that it might be there, as does the general premise.

We watch as Jacob awakes in a rice field in China, clearly in unfamiliar territory. The case soon falls to Immigration agent J. Martin Bellamy (Omar Epps), who only knows that Jacob has made his way back to the United States, but hasn’t spoken a word since he was found. Though Martin is supposed to just drop Jacob off with Child Protective Services, he seems to be getting some information out of Jacob, and when Jacob confirms that he can find his way home, in Arcadia, Missouri, Martin takes him there.

The aging man who answers the door, Henry (Kurtwood Smith), confirms that he had a son named Jacob, but that Jacob died over thirty years ago. As the title would suggest, Jacob seems to have been resurrected, a fact apparently confirmed by Jacob recognizing his father, and remembering his death.

Resurrection TV Review ABC
ABC/Bob Mahoney

You might expect that a certain amount of what happens next should be described as, well, what you’d expect to happen, but there are more complications, and what would you expect anyway?

On the other hand, as you might expect from TV land, Jacob’s parents are torn. Henry finds the whole thing hard to accept, but mom, Lucille (Frances Fisher) can’t play along fast enough.

Beyond that, Arcadia is a fairly small town, which leads to the Sheriff, Fred (Matt Craven), conveniently being Henry’s brother, and the local pastor being Jacob’s childhood friend. Complicating the situation further, Fred’s wife died in the same accident at the river as Jacob. Fred’s daughter, Maggie, who was present at the accident, but was only a baby, gets dragged into things as well, because she’s conveniently a doctor (but not overly convincing as one). She’s also conveniently best friends with Elaine, who will become more interesting as the web reaches out to turn most of Arcadia upside-down.

There’s a certain routine to the establishment of the pilot episode, mostly because we have to put together some plausible idea of what people might actually do in such a situation. DNA tests, exhuming bodies, and the trials and tribulations of same. Whatever we might endure when someone who died shows up for lunch. We have to dance through all the steps without losing hold of the audience, and it’s trickier than you might expect. It doesn’t work out perfectly, especially when looking at the first couple of episodes together, but it passes. Confusion over perhaps not announcing that your son has been resurrected is a bit tricky to swallow, but in the midst of the whole picture it is possible to play along. Other points will test a variety of viewer responses, like the rather cliche, and only passably acted, “that man in there isn’t Dad,” routine.

It actually works some decent hooks, as much as this particular spin on wild conspiracies runs the risk of going too far too fast, and with the addition of the heartstrings element, it has a lot of potential to keep viewers around. It may surprise some to learn that Omar Epps is probably the show’s best draw. Not that he hasn’t given solid performances in the past, but he hasn’t had the opportunity to try to charm his way through a role like this before, and he hasn’t managed this level of maintaining the spotlight before.

The show’s only problem may be, odd as it will sound, that it can’t seem to decide just how weird it wants to be. The juggling of levels, much as the case with LOST, keeps you guessing, but it’s difficult to know how well we’re going to get it all to mesh with small town America, as opposed to a mysterious island. This is especially true when what we’re juggling is that which is already bizarre, and the pulling back of the wizard’s curtain.

Unfortunately, what’s really going to tell you something is somewhere around the fifth or sixth episode. That’s when the show is going to have to give you enough information to see if you’ll keep playing, and that’s going to let us in on how wacky things are really going to get. For now, it’s going to hit as one of the most interesting things on television, and it isn’t going to have much trouble roping you in. It’s a well-worked sci-fi koan that balances the oddity against the fact that Kurtwood Smith is delivering some of the lines. If he can’t anchor your screwy premise, nothing can.

In the end, much of the beauty comes in the fact that, again like LOST, as certain points are revealed you can’t help but suddenly be struck with a, “Wait, what the hell am I watching here?” That’s television gold.


[springboard type=”video” id=”892825″ player=”arey029″ width=”620″ height=”380″ ]



“Resurrection” stars Omar Epps (“House”) as J. Martin Bellamy, Frances Fisher (“Titanic”) as Lucille Langston, Matt Craven (“Crimson Tide,” “A Few Good Men”) as Fred Langston, Devin Kelley (“Chernobyl Diaries,” “The Chicago Code”) as Maggie Langston, Mark Hildreth (“The Tudors”) as Pastor Tom Hale, Samaire Armstrong (“Entourage,” “The O.C.”) as Elaine Richards, Sam Hazeldine (“The Raven”) as Caleb Richards, Landon Gimenez as Jacob and Kurtwood Smith (“That ’70s Show”) as Henry Langston.



Marc Eastman
Marc Eastman is the owner and operator of Are You Screening? and has been writing film reviews for over a decade, and several branches of the internet's film review world have seen his name. He is also a member of The Broadcast Film Critics Association and The Broadcast Television Journalists Association.

Must Read

Tenet Review – Nolan Overworks An Odd, Confused Plot – Which Is The Brand Now

Whatever your feelings about Christopher Nolan's films, it's hard to deny that he has a very specific vision of filmcraft, and that...

Critics Choice Association Announces Critics Choice Super Awards

The Critics Choice Awards have long tried to focus attention on more than just the biggest names and titles, and/or those destined...

Artemis Fowl Review – Disney Treatment Flits About Too Quickly

Much like the book, Disney's adaptation of Artemis Fowl is more concerned with not losing its audience...


Mr. Mercedes Review – King Adaptation Is Brilliant But Drags

Mr. Mercedes is a certain sort of triumph, but it isn't going to be for everyone. It's a great character study, and you'll wish you could binge it, but you'll also want to fast-forward.

Man With A Plan Review – TV – Matt LeBlanc’s New Average In, Average Out

Matt LeBlanc tries like hell, but he can't save the writing here, which hopes so hard to be mediocre that it can't possibly miss.

The Haunting of Hill House Review – Netflix Demolishes Genre Of Unease

The horror genre has always been overflowing with analogy and representation, whether the monster du jour is a stand in for societal...

Dont' Miss The Best Of The Decade