We managed to disagree by our widest margin, and no one would have guessed the film that brought us apart.
Logan caught us by surprise, even when we were expecting good things. It's an excellent effort that oddly enough makes us excited and nervous when it comes to the future of comic book films.
We're running through the best and the worst of 2016, as well as reviewing Get Out.
It's a crazy mix as we try to catch up, and do a bad job frankly.
10 Cloverfield Lane didn't impress... and the worst movies of the year didn't either...
It's the best of the year, and this one goes to 11... or 30... or we just talk about tons of films.
Unbroken and Boyhood didn't impress, but at least we got to talk about some that we think we will.
It was a crazy week that packed in more than we could possibly talk about, but we also managed to cover The Imitation Game and Into the Woods.
Birdman may have been the clear winner this week, but I rated Big Eyes even higher.