Younger is the first decent show of its genre to come along in several years, and Sutton Foster should be able to connect you with this one. The potential alone is worth giving this one a shot, and if there's a chance you'll like it, the smart money is on settling in for your new favorite show.
One Big Happy needs you to settle in with it. It's working a theory that you'll like these people, as opposed to having to make you laugh ten times a minute. It has the cast to pull it off, and if you're on board for something that is insanely fun, instead of funny, you'll be glad you gave it a shot.
The Slap is a good idea (with a silly name) that goes too far to ultimately maintain its own effort. It's guilty pleasure at best, and hard to distinguish from soap operas, except for its delusions of grandeur.