Wisdom of the Crowd is a solid effort that works its gimmick in a way that is potentially gripping, but it needs to make sure it's working the balance of characters.
Adam Scott and Craig Robinson both deserve better writing and there isn't enough in this pilot to believe that they're going to get it. It may transform into a solid show in a few episodes, but it doesn't seem the way to bet.
The Gifted is potentially the show everyone will be talking about, and the pilot is brilliant. The trick is that it doesn't tell you where you're going and a few episodes in you might end up watching a completely different show.
Kevin (Probably) Saves The World is poised to take audiences on a wild ride they never knew they were missing, and the show is worth watching for Jason Ritter alone.
Young Sheldon has a star that deserves a hit show on his own, and solid potential besides, but the realm of gimmick, family comedy is overloaded and this is one that could easily spin out of control.